Blog science

Trichotillomania & John Kender Diet: Do Sugar and Caffeine Really Increase the Urge to Pull?

Hi friends! As a coffee-addicted chocolate and sugar fiend, I’ve been both horrified and intrigued by comments I’ve seen people on Facebook about having a reduction in urges by cutting caffeine and sugar. Does that really work? Read on to find out!

The John Kender Diet

pexels-photo-704971

John Kender is a computer science professor at Columbia University in New York City. He believes that eating certain foods can aggravate trichotillomania. Over time, with much trial and error with his trichster daughter’s diet, he has developed a diet plan of foods to stay away from in order to decrease pulling urges (Trichotillomania Support).

Note: There are no medical studies to support his connection between diet and trichotillomania (TRIB LIVE).

Malassezia: The Basis of the JK Diet

microscope-slide-research-close-up-60022

JK’s main idea is that trichsters experience itchiness and irritation from a naturally occurring stomach and skin yeast called Malassezia. The foods that are said to “increase urges” are those that are known to increase Malassezia.

Looking up Malassezia led me to seborrheic dermatitis (SD). According to a study completed by The Journal of Clinical and Aesthetic Dermatology, there is a strong correlation between SD flares and the proliferation of Malassezia species. This is important to know because there are also recommended diet do’s and don’ts for those with SD.

The Mercola Seborrheic Dermatitis Diet

pexels-photo-204692

The fact that seborrheic dermatitis has a recommended diet is interesting to me because if these recommended foods work for SD (by limiting Malassezia), then maybe they could work for getting rid of trichotillomania urges which are linked to Malassezia (as John Kender’s theory says).

So, I found Dr. Mercola’s Seborrheic Dermatitis diet. However, upon reading the fine print, the post says “The entire contents of this website are based upon the opinions of Dr. Mercola, unless otherwise noted.” Does that mean there is no scientific backing for this diet as well? I honestly don’t know and couldn’t find out.

Below, I compare and contrast the two diets which focus on limiting Malassezia, which may be linked to hair pulling urges in trichotillomania.

DO: Foods That Decrease Urges/Malassezia

* = use sparingly, bolded = same for both diets, underlined = conflicting between diets

pexels-photo-533360

  The John Kender Diet & The JK Diet for Vegetarians/Vegans Seborrheic Dermatitis Diet
Vegetables Onions, cabbage, brussels sprouts, spinach, lettuce, tomatoes (no seeds), mushrooms, squash, eggplant, broccoli, asparagus, peppers, carrots Leafy green vegetables like broccoli, spinach, kale and collard greens. Vitamin A-rich foods like carrots, Swiss chard, watercress and pumpkin. Vitamin B-rich foods that contain biotin or vitamin B7 like cabbage, green peas and sweet potatoes. Vitamin C-rich foods like artichokes, tomatoes, bell peppers, brussels sprouts and cauliflower. Chili peppers and shiitake mushrooms.
Spices/Seasoning Garlic, ginger root, sea salt*, marinara*, salad dressing*, salsa* Cloves, ginger, rosemary, turmeric, cinnamon, oregano, marjoram, sage, thyme, garlic
Fruit Oranges, tangelos, tangerines apples, lemons, cherries, kiwi, limes, ripening bananas, papaya, guava, pineapple, raspberries, blueberries, strawberries, peaches, grapes, watermelon, melons, mango, pears Antioxidant rich food like strawberries*, cherries*, blueberries*, organic apples and bananas, papaya
Healthy Fats Avocados* Vitamin E-rich foods like avocados and almonds
Fermented Foods Kefir Kefir, natto, kimchi, miso, tempeh and sauerkraut.
Meat/Seafood (Protein) Beef, cod, halibut, turbot, flounder, haddock, sole, monkfish, red snapper, sea bass  
Alcohol Red wine, beer*, ales*, lagers*  
Other Decaffeinated tea, mustard, unsweetened live yogurt, Stevia, carob, granola, rice milk, rice cream, rice butter, low-fat peanut butter, provolone and swiss cheeses, skim milk, cream cheese, sour cream non whole grain items (wheat pasta, wheat  flour tortillas, low-carb bread)*, sunflower oil*, vinegars*, rice*, Asian noodles* Flax seeds, organic whole psyllium husk, wheat germ

DON’T: Foods That Increase Urges/Malassezia

* = use sparingly, bolded = same for both diets, underlined = conflicting between diets

stop-shield-traffic-sign-road-sign-39080

  The John Kender Diet & The JK Diet for Vegetarians/Vegans Seborrheic Dermatitis Diet
Excessive amounts of saturated fats Butterfat, eggs Refined and processed foods, butter, eggs, hydrogenated vegetable oils, coconut products (however, for health, eat minimal portions)
Refined sugar Sugars and aspartame sweeteners, chocolate All refined sugar
Dairy products   All dairy products
Soy products All soy products  
Caffeine All caffeine (coffee, tea) Coffee
Fruits Grapefuits Citrus fruits such as oranges, blood oranges, clementines, limes, grapefruits, lemons, mandarin oranges, tangelos, yuzu
Vegetables Corn (popcorn, corn tortillas and corn chips), alfafa sprouts, peas Corn
Meat/Seafood (Protein) Crustaceans (lobster, prawns, crab), fatty fish (tuna, herring), sardines, salmon, mackerel, most shellfish (mussels, shrimp), legumes (beans and lentils) Red meat
Other Tomato seeds, nuts (especially peanuts), glucose, monosodium glutamate, nitrites, aspartate/asparagine, gin, MSG Peanuts, gluten-loaded products, wheat products

 

TL;DR – What Both Diets Agree On

* = in moderation

pexels-photo-461431

  DO EAT DO NOT EAT
Vegetables Cabbage, brussels sprouts, spinach, mushrooms, broccoli, peppers, carrots, tomatoes (if you remove the seeds) Corn (all corn products too such as corn tortillas, corn chips and popcorn)
Fruits Apples, bananas, papaya, cherries*, blueberries*, strawberries* Grapefruits
Fats Avocados* Butter, eggs
Caffeine Decaf coffee, decaf tea All caffeine (coffee, tea)
Sugar   All refined sugar (as in chocolate), aspartame sweeteners
Fermented Foods Kefir  
Other   Peanuts

Discussion

pexels-photo-1282276

Both diets have very specific suggestions, some of which overlap and some of which contradict one another. If they are both based on any sort of science at all, I couldn’t find it. So, for now, I’m going to look only at the foods both diets agree on, one side testing for trich-applicability and the other side testing for effectiveness against Malassezia.

It seems like the two biggest areas which I consume daily are the caffeine and sugar categories. I’m a HUGE coffee, tea and chocolate fan. The other day, I drank some Hershey’s chocolate syrup from the bottle. That happened. It was great. However, one of the main components in both diets is to cut all caffeine (bye coffee & tea) and processed sugar (bye chocolate). Maybe that wouldn’t be a huge problem for others, but it is for me. I’ve had daily coffee and chocolate (and usually tea) for about a decade.

My Test (Wish Me Luck!)

pexels-photo-984538

To really test this out, I’ve decided to try cutting out processed sugars and caffeine from my diet. I’ve been doing this for a few days and so far I’ve switched to decaf tea and coffee and found sweet alternatives to processed sugar such as: unsweetened soy milk, honey, unsweetened strawberry jam, maple syrup, dried pineapple and dried mango.

I recognize that I’m still going to consume some things on the overall “naughty list” such as: unsweetened soy milk, tofu, beans, oranges, corn and peanuts. As I said, I’m only going to focus on caffeine and processed sugar for the moment — both because I live in a place where vegetarian alternatives are hard to find and also for my sanity.

I’m trying to see if cutting caffeine and processed sugar will be effective on their own. However, I don’t want to completely demolish any hope I have for sticking with this diet, so I’m allowing 1 sweet/choco treat on the weekend (to give its effects time to wear off when I don’t have any work-induced stress). Wish me luck!

Ultimate Goal

pexels-photo-350345

My ultimate goal is to have the urges reduce or vanish. A part of me thinks that perhaps caffeine and processed sugar are boosting anxiety or jitteriness. Perhaps cutting out my normal coffee, tea and chocolate will actually reduce anxiety and jitters, not necessarily the Malassezia. Either way, whether its linked to anxiety/jitters or Malassezia, all I care about is that the urges might go away. I hope so!

Share Your Diet Story

sketch-3042584_960_720

Have you been on either of these diets? Did they work? Did they not work? I’d love to hear from you about your trich-related diet experiences. I hope you found this article helpful, useful or interesting. I’ll update later on after enough time as passed. For more trich and BFRB-related goodies, head to Facebook or Twitter. Thanks so much for reading, and as always, take care of yourself. xx Rexie

pexels-photo-255379

**Disclaimer: No copyright infringement intended. If you have an issue with any of the images, please let me know and I will take it down immediately. Thanks!**

Resources:

The Journal of Clinical and Aesthetic Dermatology, “Seborrheic Dermatitis and Malassezia species: How Are They Related?”

Mercola, “What Must Be in Your Diet If You Have Seborrheic Dermatitis?”

TRIB LIVE, “Hair-pullers suffer in secret”

Trichotillomania Support, “The John Kender Diet For Trichotillomania”

Trichotillomania Support, “The John Kender Diet for Vegetarians and Vegans”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: